Mets and Yankees 2025 MLB season predictions for final record, team MVP, and more

Here are Mets and Yankees predictions from SNY staff and contributors for final records, team MVP, and more for the 2025 MLB season...

Andy Martino, SNY MLB Insider

Who will the Mets' MVP be? Juan Soto
Over/under .950 OPS for Juan Soto? Over
Over/under 40 home runs for Pete Alonso? Over
What will Clay Holmes' ERA be? 3.40
Which prospect will have the biggest MLB impact? Luisangel Acuña
Where will Mets finish in NL East? First
What will Mets' final record be? 93-69

Who will the Yankees' MVP be? Aaron Judge
Over/under 50 home runs for Aaron Judge? Under
Over/under 25 home runs for Cody Bellinger? Over
What willMax Fried's ERA be? 3.00
Which prospect will make the biggest MLB impact? Jasson Dominguez
Where will Yankees finish in AL East? Second
What will Yankees' final record be? 88-74

Todd Zeile, SNY Mets Analyst

Who will the Mets' MVP be? Francisco Lindor
Over/under .950 OPS for Juan Soto? Over
Over/under 40 home runs forPete Alonso? Over
What will Clay Holmes' ERA be? 2.79
Which prospect will have the biggest MLB impact? Luisangel Acuña
Where will Mets finish in NL East? First
What will Mets' final record be? 93-69

Who will the Yankees' MVP be? Aaron Judge
Over/under 50 home runs for Aaron Judge? Over
Over/under 25 home runs for Cody Bellinger? Under
What will Max Fried's ERA be? 3.05
Which prospect will make the biggest MLB impact? Jasson Dominguez
Where will Yankees finish in AL East? First
What will Yankees' final record be? 97-65

Jim Duquette, SNY Mets Analyst

Who will the Mets' MVP be? Juan Soto
Over/under .950 OPS for Juan Soto? Over
Over/under 40 home runs for Pete Alonso? Over
What will Clay Holmes' ERA be? 3.75
Which prospect will have the biggest MLB impact? Brandon Sproat
Where will Mets finish in NL East? Second
What will Mets' final record be? 90-72

Who will the Yankees' MVP be? Aaron Judge
Over/under 50 home runs for Aaron Judge? Under
Over/under 25 home runs for Cody Bellinger? Over
What will Max Fried's ERA be? 3.25
Which prospect will make the biggest MLB impact? Jasson Dominguez
Where will Yankees finish in AL East? First
What will Yankees' final record be? 92-70

Terry Collins, SNY Mets Analyst

Who will the Mets' MVP be? Francisco Lindor
Over/under .950 OPS for Juan Soto? Over
Over/under 40 home runs for Pete Alonso? Over
What will Clay Holmes' ERA be? 3.25
Which prospect will have the biggest MLB impact? Luisangel Acuña
Where will Mets finish in NL East? First
What will Mets' final record be? 97-65

Who will the Yankees' MVP be? Paul Goldschmidt
Over/under 50 home runs for Aaron Judge? Over
Over/under 25 home runs for Cody Bellinger? Over
What will Max Fried's ERA be? 3.72
Which prospect will make the biggest MLB impact? Jasson Dominguez
Where will Yankees finish in AL East? First
What will Yankees' final record be? 93-69

Sal Licata, BNNY Host

Who will the Mets' MVP be? Juan Soto
Over/under .950 OPS for Juan Soto? Over
Over/under 40 home runs for Pete Alonso? Under
What will Clay Holmes' ERA be? 3.86
Which prospect will have the biggest MLB impact? Brandon Sproat
Where will Mets finish in NL East? First
What will Mets' final record be? 97-65

Who will the Yankees' MVP be? Cody Bellinger
Over/under 50 home runs for Aaron Judge? Under
Over/under 25 home runs for Cody Bellinger? Over
What will Max Fried's ERA be? 2.89
Which prospect will make the biggest MLB impact? Jasson Dominguez
Where will Yankees finish in AL East? Second
What will Yankees' final record be? 89-73

John Harper, SNY Contributor

Who will the Mets' MVP be? Juan Soto
Over/under .950 OPS for Juan Soto? Over
Over/under 40 home runs for Pete Alonso? Under
What will Clay Holmes' ERA be? 2.98
Which prospect will have the biggest MLB impact? Brandon Sproat
Where will Mets finish in NL East? Third
What will Mets' final record be? 91-71

Who will the Yankees' MVP be? Aaron Judge
Over/under 50 home runs for Aaron Judge? Over
Over/under 25 home runs for Cody Bellinger? Over
What will Max Fried's ERA be? 3.18
Which prospect will make the biggest MLB impact? Jasson Dominguez
Where will Yankees finish in AL East? Third
What will Yankees' final record be? 90-72

Anthony McCarron, SNY Contributor

Who will the Mets' MVP be? Juan Soto
Over/under .950 OPS for Juan Soto? Over
Over/under 40 home runs for Pete Alonso? Over
What will Clay Holmes' ERA be? 3.65
Which prospect will have the biggest MLB impact? Brandon Sproat
Where will Mets finish in NL East? Third
What will Mets' final record be? 89-73

Who will the Yankees' MVP be? Aaron Judge
Over/under 50 home runs for Aaron Judge? Over
Over/under 25 home runs for Cody Bellinger? Over
What will Max Fried's ERA be? 3.15
Which prospect will make the biggest MLB impact? Will Warren
Where will Yankees finish in AL East? Third
What will Yankees' final record be? 88-74

Dani Wexelman, SNY Contributor

Who will the Mets' MVP be? Francisco Lindor
Over/under .950 OPS for Juan Soto? Over
Over/under 40 home runs for Pete Alonso? Under
What will Clay Holmes' ERA be? 3.50
Which prospect will have the biggest MLB impact? Luisangel Acuña
Where will Mets finish in NL East? Third
What will Mets' final record be? 89-73

Who will the Yankees' MVP be? Aaron Judge
Over/under 50 home runs for Aaron Judge? Over
Over/under 25 home runs for Cody Bellinger? Under
What will Max Fried's ERA be? 2.20
Which prospect will make the biggest MLB impact? Jasson Dominguez
Where will Yankees finish in AL East? Second
What will Yankees' final record be? 89-73

Hannah Keyser, SNY Contributor

Who will the Mets' MVP be? Juan Soto
Over/under .950 OPS for Juan Soto? Under
Over/under 40 home runs for Pete Alonso? Over
What will Clay Holmes' ERA be? 3.83
Which prospect will have the biggest MLB impact? Brandon Sproat
Where will Mets finish in NL East? Second
What will Mets' final record be? 89-73

Who will the Yankees' MVP be? Max Fried
Over/under 50 home runs for Aaron Judge? Under
Over/under 25 home runs for Cody Bellinger? Under
What will Max Fried's ERA be? 2.49
Which prospect will make the biggest MLB impact? Will Warren
Where will Yankees finish in AL East? Second
What will Yankees' final record be? 89-73

Connor Rogers, The Mets Pod Co-host

Who will the Mets' MVP be? Juan Soto
Over/under .950 OPS for Juan Soto? Under
Over/under 40 home runs for Pete Alonso? Over
What will Clay Holmes' ERA be? 3.70
Which prospect will have the biggest MLB impact? Brandon Sproat
Where will Mets finish in NL East? Second
What will Mets' final record be? 91-71

Who will the Yankees' MVP be? Aaron Judge
Over/under 50 home runs for Aaron Judge? Under
Over/under 25 home runs for Cody Bellinger? Under
What will Max Fried's ERA be? 2.96
Which prospect will make the biggest MLB impact? Will Warren
Where will Yankees finish in AL East? Second
What will Yankees' final record be? 85-77

Joe DeMayo, The Mets Pod Co-host

Who will the Mets' MVP be? Francisco Lindor
Over/under .950 OPS for Juan Soto? Under
Over/under 40 home runs for Pete Alonso? Over
What will Clay Holmes' ERA be? 3.33
Which prospect will have the biggest MLB impact? Brandon Sproat
Where will Mets finish in NL East? Second
What will Mets' final record be? 95-67

Who will the Yankees' MVP be? Aaron Judge
Over/under 50 home runs for Aaron Judge? Over
Over/under 25 home runs for Cody Bellinger? Under
What will Max Fried's ERA be? 3.18
Which prospect will make the biggest MLB impact? Jasson Dominguez
Where will Yankees finish in AL East? First
What will Yankees' final record be? 98-64

Danny Abriano, SNY Manager of Editorial Production

Who will the Mets' MVP be? Francisco Lindor
Over/under .950 OPS forJuan Soto? Over
Over/under 40 home runs forPete Alonso? Under
What will Clay Holmes' ERA be? 3.49
Which prospect will have the biggest MLB impact? Brandon Sproat
Where will Mets finish in NL East? Second
What will Mets' final record be? 94-68

Who will the Yankees' MVP be? Aaron Judge
Over/under 50 home runs for Aaron Judge? Under
Over/under 25 home runs for Cody Bellinger? Under
What will Max Fried's ERA be? 3.38
Which prospect will make the biggest MLB impact? Will Warren
Where will Yankees finish in AL East? Third
What will Yankees' final record be? 91-71

Alex Smith, SNY Editorial Producer

Who will the Mets' MVP be? Juan Soto
Over/under .950 OPS for Juan Soto? Over
Over/under 40 home runs for Pete Alonso? Under
What will Clay Holmes' ERA be? 3.89
Which prospect will have the biggest MLB impact? Nolan McLean
Where will Mets finish in NL East? Second
What will Mets' final record be? 92-70

Who will the Yankees' MVP be? Cody Bellinger
Over/under 50 home runs for Aaron Judge? Under
Over/under 25 home runs for Cody Bellinger? Over
What will Max Fried's ERA be? 3.04
Which prospect will make the biggest MLB impact? Will Warren
Where will Yankees finish in AL East? Third
What will Yankees' final record be? 88-74

Phillip Martinez, SNY Editorial Producer

Who will the Mets' MVP be? Juan Soto
Over/under .950 OPS for Juan Soto? Under
Over/under 40 home runs for Pete Alonso? Under
What will Clay Holmes' ERA be? 3.95
Which prospect will have the biggest MLB impact? Brandon Sproat
Where will Mets finish in NL East? Third
What will Mets' final record be? 90-72

Who will the Yankees' MVP be? Aaron Judge
Over/under 50 home runs for Aaron Judge? Under
Over/under 25 home runs for Cody Bellinger? Over
What will Max Fried's ERA be? 2.86
Which prospect will make the biggest MLB impact? Jasson Dominguez
Where will Yankees finish in AL East? First
What will Yankees' final record be? 93-69